Jumbo Peanut Butter: Good Enuf for Me

Jumbo Peanut Butter: Good Enuf for Me

Peanut butter is a staple of the average American kitchen.   It’s a favorite in the lunch boxes of school age children, college students, and archaeologist’s in the field. And although the peanut has been widely cultivated for a long time, peanut butter as we know it today only dates to the late 1800s. In 1895 John Harvey Kellogg (yes that’s Kellogg) applied for a U.S. patent for a nut butter made from peanuts or almonds. By 1896 the Kellogg Company was producing nut butter on a small scale. By the turn of the century peanut butter was fairly widely available from commercial sources, as it gained popularity following the 1904 St. Louis World’s Fair. By 1922 there’s even a National Peanut Butter Manufacturers Association (Shurtleff and Aoyagi 2015).

Jumbo Peanut Butter Jar from Brody/Emmons complex.
Jumbo Peanut Butter Jar from Brody/Emmons complex.

There’s a single peanut butter jar recovered from the Brody/Emmons amphitheater excavations: Frank’s Tea & Spice Company Jumbo Peanut Butter. In 1896, Jacob, Emil, and Charles Frank founded the Frank Tea & Spice Company in Cincinnati, Ohio. The company originally sold small, shelf-size packages of whole and ground spices. They later expanded their offerings to tea, spices, peanut butter, and olives (American Jewish Archive). However, their most famous and most enduring product was Frank’s RedHot® hot sauce, first produced in 1920 (www.franksredhot.com). Unfortunately this jar doesn’t have any makers mark or date stamps.  The overall construction of the jar, and the date range of the other artifacts recovered from the Brody/Emmons complex suggests that this jar is from the 1930s.

Information about their Jumbo brand peanut butter is spotty. We know that the Frank Tea & Spice Company applied for a trademark on the world “Jumbo” in 1927 (Shurtleff and Aoyagi 2015). So, why Jumbo peanut butter? To unwrap this decision, we need to look to the elephant on the jar.

Jumbo and his caretaker. Image source.
Jumbo and his caretaker. Image source.

Well, today jumbo as a word is part of every day speech – a word to describe something that is large. Merriam-Webster notes that the first use of the word was only in 1883. That’s because the common use of the word comes from Jumbo the Elephant. Jumbo was the most famous elephant of the 19th century. He was sold to the London Zoo in 1865, and became famous for giving rides to visitors. Jumbo was fold in 1882 to Barnum & Bailey Circus, where he quickly became their most popular attraction. Jumbo was a beloved public figure and was featured on soda bottles, popcorn bags, matches, playing cards, puzzle, children’s toys, and even used as advertisement for tires and spark plugs (http://now.tufts.edu/articles/glory-was-jumbo).

Jumbo smoking tobacco ad. Image source.
Jumbo smoking tobacco ad. Image source.
Jumbo brings soap trade card. Image source.
Jumbo brings soap trade card. Image source.
Jumbo at Coney Island. Image source.
Jumbo at Coney Island. Image source.
Advertisement to see Jumbo's skeleton at the circus. Image source.
Advertisement to see Jumbo’s skeleton at the circus. Image source.

Jumbo was killed in an unfortunate train accident in 1885, but that did not mark the end of his illustrious career. Barnum had his hide taxidermied and his skeleton mounted. The skeleton and mount traveled with the circus for years. Today the skeleton is at the American Museum of Natural History in New York. The hide was donated to the P.T. Barnum Hall at Tufts’ University. Although the hide was unfortunately destroyed in a 1975 fire (Jumbo’s ashes are kept in a Peter Pan Crunchy Peanut Butter Jar in the Tufts athletic director’s office), Jumbo remains the Tufts mascot. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jumbo)

Jumbo peanut butter elephant shaped jar. Image source.
Jumbo peanut butter elephant shaped jar. Image source.

The fact that Jumbo had died more than 40 years before Jumbo Peanut Butter was produced speaks to the endurance of his legacy.  And the connection between elephants and peanuts.  Elephants don’t eat peanuts as part of their natural diets. However, roasted peanuts were popular fair at the circus, and were often purchased to feed elephants. So perhaps Frank’s Tea & Spice Company was playing on national nostalgia in naming their peanut butter Jumbo.  Although our jar only has an image of Jumbo, they also produced small jars in the shape of an elephant (wouldn’t that be fun to find!).

Jumbo Peanut Butter was also known for the eclectic sayings on the bottom of the jars including “Try Jumbo Peanut Butter Sandwiches”, “Best for the kiddies”, or like our jar says “Jumbo Good Enuf for Me”.

Bottom of Jumbo Peanut Butter jar from Brody/Emmons complex. Reads "Jumbo Good Enuf for Me".
Bottom of Jumbo Peanut Butter jar from Brody/Emmons complex. Reads “Jumbo Good Enuf for Me”.

When I started researching this peanut butter jar I never imagined I’d be learning about a famous elephant (but that’s what makes research fun!). Jumbo the elephant impacted many facets of history: rise of mass entertainment/pop culture, museums, advertisement, ever our lexicon.  To learn more about Jumbo, and the wild rumors P.T. Barnum concocted about his death, check out the information video produced by Tufts.

Author: Lisa Bright






Elephants shaped jar: https://i.pinimg.com/236x/21/1f/3a/211f3a60888660aa1849f6533a9d989d–antique-glassware-vintage-kitchenware.jpg


William Shurtleff and Akiko Aoyagi. 2015. Origin and early history of peanut butter (1884-2015): Extensively annotated bibliography and sourcebook. Soyinfo Center.

Jumbo and care taker”: http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2014/02/05/article-2552606-1B14452D00000578-388_634x589.jpg

Jumbo at coney island: http://www.heartofconeyisland.com/uploads/5/1/5/8/51585031/8778343_orig.jpg

Jumbo skeleton: http://www.ohiohistoryhost.org/ohiomemory/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/jumbo4.jpg

Jumbo trade card: http://www.gettyimages.com/detail/news-photo/soapona-ordered-this-anthropomorphic-trade-card-news-photo/93302350?esource=SEO_GIS_CDN_Redirect#soapona-ordered-this-anthropomorphic-trade-card-capitalizing-on-the-picture-id93302350

Jumbo tobacco: https://i.pinimg.com/736x/27/4c/bd/274cbdf9cfdbd25ae60362476a0c4e4c–lettering-art-advertising-signs.jpg


17 thoughts on “Jumbo Peanut Butter: Good Enuf for Me”

  • Great post, but I’m really confused about where Brody/Emmons amphitheater is. Could you or should I say, have you included a map of these areas with some of the roads surrounding the campus to give us a good reference.

  • Hi Lanny,
    Thanks for the comment, and great idea for future blog posts. The Brody dorm complex is on the corner of Harrison and Michigan. Before the dorm was built in the 50’s, it was the site of the East Lansing dump.

  • The bottom saying on my jar is: “ALL THE CHILDREN LIKE JUMBO” and there is a 7 under the saying.

  • Enjoyed your research. I found a jar fragment with enough to find your site. I live in Ripon, WI and found it in a midden by a smallish drainage gully the feeds into the mill pond. Thank you for your work.

  • How weird… I just bought a jar full of buttons about a month ago and just noticed the jar and is one original of this jumbo elephant ..

  • I have a jumbo peanut butter jar which i found while working under my home in 1976. The house was a victorian style and had been built in 1881 by Henry Rhode. So happens, Mr. Rhode was from Cinncinnati, Ohio. He, and his two brothers developed the whole area here in st Augustine, Fl. My (then house) was the first house they built on Rhode Ave(#14 on the NW corner of Rhode Ave and First St. ). It shows up on a 1885 ariel sketch made of st Augustine

  • I live in Ripon WI. I have a complete unbroken Jumbo Peanut Butter jar. On the bottom it says “Accept No Substitute For Jumbo” and it has a date of June 24 1930. Also a mark of “D 81439” and a separate number at the bottom of 5.

  • Hi Lesllie, thank you for finding this post and commenting! If you seen some of the other comments it seems like there is a large variety of slogans on the bottom of the jars. As we collect more, especially from jars with known dates, we will be able to see if there are any chronological patterns to these slogans. Thank you for helping in our research!

  • I found the peanut butter jar in the creek behind my house the house was built in 1928

  • My jar says “If You Like Jumbo Tell Your Friends” and has a 7 under the saying.

  • I live in New Albany Indiana directly across the Ohio River from Louisville Kentucky .Cincinnati is about 2 hours away. my jar has no words at all on the bottom it only has a number five. The face of the jar says jumbo brand 10 and 1/2 oz peanut butter the Frank tea and spice co .Cincinnati .O.

  • Hi..i found a jumbo peanut butter jar in my yard while getting it ready for a flower bed .. I cleaned and started my research..came across your paper..thanks for the great info..my jar is dated jun 24 1930. No lid .. but jar is in great condition

  • My great grandmother canned “something” in a jumbo peanut butter jar before her death in early 1959. The black gooey contents are still sealed inside and I don’t intend to find out what it is. Jumbo good enuf for me is on the bottom. What year do you think it’s from?

  • Hey there!

    I did a little bit of research, but haven’t come to a very definitive answer. Most listings online seem to date the jar design as beginning 1930, but I was unable to find patent/trademark information to verify this. Certainly appears to date to this era, likely between 1920 and 1940. Apologies that I couldn’t get you a more concrete response!


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *